Why You Need a Shoplifting Lawyer for Your Defense

Shoplifting Lawyer

We will help you fight your criminal charges

Navigating New York Shoplifting Laws with Professional Legal Help

Confronting shoplifting charges within the New York Penal Law’s complex framework can be intimidating. However, a seasoned York City shoplifting attorney, like Gina M. Wicik, can help to simplify the process. She can formulate robust defense strategies that can potentially lead to sentence reductions or even case dismissals. The primary objective of a skilled New York City shoplifting lawyer is to protect your legal rights throughout the legal process.

Grasping the nature of the charges you face is paramount in your legal journey. In New York, shoplifting incidents usually fall under two categories: Petit Larceny and Grand Larceny. Each comes with its own set of consequences and requires a different approach in terms of defense.

Understanding Petit Larceny Charges

In the realm of New York law, Petit Larceny refers to the theft of property valued at or under $1,000. But don’t let the term ‘petit’ fool you. The consequences can be anything but minor. Depending on the value of the stolen property, the penalties may include up to a year in jail or a fine up to $1,000.

In such situations, strong legal advocacy can prove invaluable. An experienced attorney, such as Gina M. Wicik, can potentially reduce the severity of charges.

Facing Grand Larceny Allegations

Felony grand larceny, the more severe sibling of Petit Larceny, applies to cases involving theft of property over $1,000 or specific items such as:

  • firearms
  • credit cards
  • vehicles
  • theft directly from a person

Under the broad spectrum of Grand Larceny, the severity varies, with each level carrying distinct penalties.

The different degrees of grand larceny include

  1. Fourth degree: property valued at more than $1,000 but not more than $3,000 or theft of specific items like firearms or credit cards. It’s classified as a Class E felony.
  2. Third degree: property over $3,000 or ATM theft. It is a Class D felony with sentences of up to 7 years imprisonment.
  3. Second degree: when the value of stolen property exceeds $50,000, or involves extortion. It is a Class C felony and can lead to up to 15 years of imprisonment.
  4. First degree: theft exceeding $1 million in value. It can carry a sentence of up to 25 years imprisonment.

One should be aware that legal defenses and plea offers in grand larceny cases vary by borough within New York City.

Your Rights When Accused of Shoplifting in NYC

Knowing your rights is critical when faced with shoplifting charges. In NYC, security guards can detain individuals suspected of shoplifting if there is a reasonable belief of theft. However, this suspicion cannot be based on discriminatory reasons such as race or ethnicity. They must adhere to legal limitations regarding reasonable force and duration of detention, ensuring detentions are not unreasonably long or excessively forceful.

As the accused, you have the right:

  • Not to admit guilt or sign any documents without legal counsel;
  • Even if confronted with false claims of video evidence or pressured to confess, you are under no obligation to incriminate yourself;
  • Consulting with The Law Office of Gina M, Wicik, can help determine whether these rights have been violated during a shoplifting accusation and detention.

The Consequences of a Shoplifting Conviction in New York City

The repercussions of a shoplifting conviction in NYC extend beyond the direct legal punishments. Depending on the value of stolen items and prior criminal history, penalties for shoplifting can range from fines and probation to  mandatory minimum imprisonment.

A shoplifting conviction can result in a criminal record, which may prevent individuals from renting a home, obtaining certain jobs, or securing financial aid. Furthermore, a criminal conviction could impose fines and lead to incarceration.

For non-citizens, the stakes are even higher. A shoplifting conviction can classify as a crime of moral turpitude, leading to severe immigration consequences.

Defense Strategies in Shoplifting Cases

The Law Office of Gina M. Wicik, can employ a range of defense strategies. The credibility and admissibility of the State’s evidence can be challenged in court, highlighting any weaknesses. For instance, evidence obtained through illegal means, such as during an illegal search and seizure, can be suppressed and not used in court.

Mistaken identity defenses may involve the use of surveillance footage or witness testimonies to cast doubt on the accused’s participation in the crime. Accidental actions resulting in shoplifting charges can be defended by showing there was no intent to permanently deprive the store of property, such as when an item is mistakenly not paid for.

The defense strategy can also be influenced by contextual circumstances, including the location of the suspect in the store, the manner in which they handled or misplaced items, and their behavior. The Law Office of Gina M. Wicik, can often use negotiation as a key tool to achieve outcomes like plea agreements, case dismissal for lack of evidence, or decreased charges.

Legal Representation: Why It’s Crucial for Your Shoplifting Case

The benefits of hiring The Law Office of Gina M. Wicik, for a shoplifting case in NYC include:

  • Navigating the intricate legal landscape
  • Aim to reduce or dismiss the consequences of the charges
  • Ensuring that the accused understands their legal rights and the process

The importance of legal representation also extends to court appearances following a Desk Appearance Ticket (DAT) to defend against the charges effectively.

Civil Repercussions of Shoplifting

The legal fallout from a shoplifting incident in New York isn’t confined to the criminal court. The civil outcomes may be equally intimidating. Under New York General Obligations Law § 11-105, retailers can seek civil damages from individuals who commit shoplifting.

New York law, allows retailers to sue shoplifters for the following:

  • Up to five times the value of the stolen merchandise
  • The value of the stolen property
  • Additional monetary penalties
  • Attorney fees from the offender

Retailers may initiate civil lawsuits to recover these damages.

Retailers can issue civil demand letters to individuals caught shoplifting, seeking reimbursement for the retailer’s losses and expenses incurred from the theft, inclusive of legal fees. While not all ignored civil demand letters result in further legal action, retailers may choose to file lawsuits or press criminal charges depending on the severity and cost-effectiveness.

The Process After an Arrest: From Desk Appearance Ticket to Court

Upon arrest for petit theft in New York City, individuals usually receive a desk appearance ticket (DAT) directing them to appear for arraignment in court on a specified date. A DAT is a written notice directing a defendant to appear in criminal court for an alleged crime, typically used for misdemeanor charges. It represents the beginning of the criminal process.
The DAT court appearance, known as an arraignment, is when the accused will be informed about the charges, and they may enter a plea. Possible bail settings might also be discussed during this hearing.
Failure to appear at court on the return date can result in a bench warrant for the individual’s arrest, potentially leading to incarceration and an arrest at home or the workplace.

Why should I hire a Criminal Defense Attorney

Navigating the complex landscape of New York City shoplifting laws can be a daunting task. But armed with the help of The Law Office of Gina M. Wicik, you can confidently face the charges and aim for the best possible outcome. From understanding the intricacies of petit and grand larceny charges to knowing your rights when accused and the potential repercussions of a conviction.
Remember, securing a seasoned New York City shoplifting lawyer, like Gina M. Wicik, is not only beneficial but crucial. We can guide you through the legal proceedings, ensure your rights are protected, and use our  experience and knowledge to aim for case dismissal or sentence reduction. No matter the circumstances, don’t lose hope, The Law Office of Gina M. Wicik, can make all the difference. Contact us for a free case consultation. Gina M. Wicik has successfully litigated thousands of criminal cases, and she’s ready to help you, 516-253-4278!

Let Us Handle it


Free Consultation

Reach out to an experienced lawyer and request a free initial consultation


Customized Defense

We work closely with our clients to develop a comprehensive personalized defense


Proven Record

With years of experience and in depth knowledge of the court system, we have the expertise to fight for you

Top Rated New York City Attorney

I highly recommend the services of Gina M Wicik for anyone in need of legal representation. I recently hired her to handle my case, and I was extremely impressed by her professionalism, knowledge, and dedication to my case.

-Greg B 

Gina M. Wicik

Any Questions?

    Get in Touch With a Winning Team That Delivers!

    Kickstart Your Defense
    With a FREE Consultation

    Excellent Client Reviews

    Excellent Client Reviews

    Customized Defense

    Customized Defense

    Comprehensive Representation

    Comprehensive Representation

    We Get the Results You Need

    We Get the Results You Need

    Copyrights 2024 Law Office Gina M. Wicik .

    all rights reserved | digital agency : hauerpower.com

    Skip to content